王艳;阚铄;

• 1:广东财经大学会计学院
• 2:中国人民大学财政金融学院

摘要(Abstract)：

鉴于从企业文化维度分析公司并购价值创造问题的研究尚比较缺乏,本文从企业组织行为特征的角度量化收购方企业文化强度,研究了其对并购绩效的影响。通过对中国A股上市公司并购事件的实证检验,本文发现收购方企业文化强度越强,并购的长期绩效表现越差。同时,对于并购非上市公司、并购行业不相关企业或进行跨省份并购等并购双方文化融合难度更大的并购事件,企业文化强度对并购绩效的负面影响更为明显。本文的研究结果说明企业文化强度是能够解释并购为何不能为收购方创造价值的重要影响因素,为并购绩效影响因素的研究提供了新的分析角度与经验证据。

关键词(KeyWords)： 企业文化;兼并收购;并购绩效

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation):

作者(Authors): 王艳;阚铄;

DOI: 10.19744/j.cnki.11-1235/f.2014.11.014

参考文献(References)：

• (1)Aaker,Jennifer L.,1997,"Dimensions of Brand Personality",Journal of Marketing Research,pp.347-356.
• (2)Abrahamson,E.and C.J.Fombrun,1994,"Macrocultures:Determinants and Consequences".Academy of Management Review,19(4),pp.728-755.
• (3)Ahem,K.R.,Daminelli,D.,Fracassi,C.,2012,"Lost in Translation?The Effect of Cultural Values on Mergers Around the World",Journal of Financial Economics,forthcoming.
• (4)Aliberti,V.and Green,M.,1999,"A Spatio-temporal Examination of Canada's Domestic Merger Activity,1971-1991",Cahiers de Geographie du Quebec,119,pp.239-250.
• (5)Ang,J.and Kohers,N.,2001,"The Take-over Market for Privately Held Companies:The US Experience",Cambridge Journal of Economics,25(6),pp.723-748.
• (6)Ashbaugh-Skaife,H.,Collins,Daniel W.,Kinney Jr.William R,LaFond,Ryan,2008,"The Effect of SOX Internal Control Deficiencies and Their Remediation on Accrual Quality",The Accounting Review,83(1),pp.217-250.
• (7)Bargeron,L.,Lehn,K.,Smith,J.,2012,"Corporate Culture and M&A Activity",Available at SSRN 2096242.
• (8)Bharadwaj,A.and Shivdasani,A.,2003,"Valuation Effects of Bank Financing in Acquisitions",Journal of Financial Economics,67(1),pp.113-148.
• (9)Bhaumik,S.K.and Selarka,E.,2012,"Does Ownership Concentration Improve M&A Outcomes in Emerging Markets?:Evidence from India",Journal of Corporate Finance,18(4),pp.717-726.
• (10)Brown,S.J.and J.B.Warner,1985,"Using Daily Stock Returns:The Case of Event Studies".Journal of Financial Economics,14(1),pp.3-31.
• (11)Bruner,R.F,2002,"Does M&A pay?A Survey of Evidence for the Decision—Maker",Journal of Applied Finance,12(1).pp.48-68.
• (12)Burt,R.S.,Gabbay,S.M.,Holt,G.,Moran,R.,1994,"Contingent Organization as A Network Theory:The Culture-Performance Contingency Function,ActaSociologica,37(4),pp.345-370.
• (13)Cai,Y.and Sevilir,M.,2012,"Board Connections and M&A Transactions",Journal of Financial Economics,103(2),pp.327-349.
• (14)Cameron Kim.S.and E.Quinn Robert.1999,Diagnosing and Changing Organizational Culture,Bk:Addison-Wesley Publishing Company.
• (15)Carroll,C.D.,Overland,J.,Weil,D.N,2000."Saving and Growth with Habit Formation,American Economic Review,pp.341-355.
• (16)Cartwright,S.and Schoenberg,R.,2006,"Thirty Years of Mergers and Acquisitions Research:Recent Advances and Future Opportunities".British Journal of Management,17(SI).pp.S1-S5.
• (17)Chatterjee,S.,Lubatkin,M.H..Schweiger,D.M..Weber,Y.,1992,"Cultural Differences and Shareholder Value in Related Mergers:Linking Equity and Human Capital",Strategic Management Journal,13(5),pp.319-334.
• (18)Chen,Z.,Lam,W.,Zhong,J.A.,2007,"Leader-member Exchange and Member Performance:A New Look at Individual-level Negative Feedback-seeking Behavior and Team-level Empowerment Climate",Journal of Applied Psychology,92(1),pp.202-212.
• (19)Christensen,H.K.and C.A.Montgomery,1981,"Corporate Economic Performance:Diversification Strategy Versus Market Structure",Strategic Management Journal,2(4),pp.327-343.
• (20)Datta,D.K..Pinches,G.E.,Narayanan,VK.,1992,"Factors Influencing Wealth Creation from Mergers and Acquisitions:A Meta-analysis',Strategic Management Journal,13(1),pp.67-84.
• (21)Datta.D.K.and Puia,G..1995,"Cross-border Acquisitions:An Examination of the Influence of Relatedness and Cultural Fit on Shareholder Value Creation in US Acquiring Firms",MIR:Management International Review,pp.337-359.
• (22)De Vries.M.F.R.K.and Miller,D.,1986,"Personality,Culture and Organization",Academy of Management Review,11(2).pp.266-279.
• (23)Deetz,S.A,1982,"Critical Interpretive Research in Organizational Communication",Western Journal of Communication(Includes Communication Reports),46(2),pp.131-149.
• (24)Denison,D.R.,1990,Corporate Culture and Organizational Effectiveness,John Wiley&Sons.
• (25)Di Giovanni,J.,2005,"What Drives Capital Flows?The Case of Cross-border M&A Activity and Financial Deepening",Journal of international Economics,65(1),pp.127-149.
• (26)Faccio,M.and R.W.Masulis,2005,"The Choice of Payment Method in European Mergers and Acquisitions",The Journal of Finance,60(3),pp.1345-1388.
• (27)Gordon,G.G.and N.DiTomaso,1992,"Predicting Corporate Performance from Organizational Culture",Journal of Management Studies,29(6),pp.783~798.
• (28)Guest,P.M.,Cosh,A.,Hughes.A.,Conn,R.L.,2004,"Why Must All Good Things Come to An End?The Performance Multiple Acquirers",Academy of Management,pp.S1-S6.
• (29)Gundry,L.K.and Rousseau,D.M.,1994,"Critical Incidents in Communicating Culture to Newcomers:The Meaning is the Message",Human Relations,47(9),pp.1063-1088.
• (30)Harrison,G.L.,McKinnon,J.L.,Panchapakesan,S.,Leung,M.,1994,"The Influence of Culture on Organizational Design and Planning and Control in Australia and the United States Compared with Singapore and Hong Kong",Journal of International Financial Management&Accounting,5(3),pp.242-261.
• (31)Haspeslagh,P.C.and Jemison,D.B,1991,Managing Acquisitions:Creating Value through Corporate Renewal,Free Press New York.
• (32)Hermalin,B.,2001,"An Economist's View of Corporate Culture",Handbook of Corporate Culture,forthcoming.
• (33)Hofsede,G.,Bram,N.,Daval,O.D.,Geert,S.,1990,"Measuring Organizational Cultures:A Qualitative and Quantitative Study Across Twenty Clases",Administrative Science Quarterly,35,pp.286-316.
• (34)Kavanagh,M.H.and Ashkanasy,N.M.,2006,"The Impact of Leadership and Change Management Strategy on Organizational Culture and Individual Acceptance of Change During A Merger",British Journal of Management,17(S1),pp.S81-S103.
• (35)King,D.R.,Dalton,D.R.,Daily,C.M.,Covin,J.G.,2004,"Meta-analyses of Post-acquisition Performance:Indications of Unidentified Moderators",Strategic Management Journal,25(2),pp.187-200.
• (36)King,D.R.,Slotegraaf,R.J.,Kesner,I.,2008,"Performance Implications of Firm Resource Interactions in the Acquisition of R&D-intensive Firms",Organization Science,19(2),pp.327-340.
• (37)Kolter,J.P.and Heskett,J.L.,1992,Corporate Culture and Performance,New York:FreePress.
• (38)Kreps,D.M.,1990,"Corporate Culture and Economic Theory",Perspectives on Positive Political Economy,90,pp.109-110.
• (39)Larsson,R.and Finkelstein,S.,1999,"Integrating Strategic,Organizational.and Human Resource Perspectives on Mergers and Acquisitions:A Case Survey of Synergy Realization",Organization Science,10(1),pp.1-26.
• (40)Lazear.E.P.,1995,"Corporate Culture and the Diffusion of Values",Trends in Business Organization:Do Participation and Cooperation Increase Competitiveness,pp.89-133.
• (41)Levinthal,D.A.,1991,"Organizational Adaptation and Environmental Selection-Interrelated Processes of Change",Organization Science,2(1),pp.140-145.
• (42)Lin,C.Y.-Y.and Wei,Y.-C.2006,"The Role of Business Ethics in Merger and Acquisition Success:An Empirical Study",Journal of Business Ethics,69(1),pp.95~109.
• (43)Loughran,T.and A.M.Vijh,1997."Do Long-term Shareholders Benefit from Corporate Acquisitions?",The Journal of Finance,52(5),pp.1765-1790.
• (44)Maloney,M.T.,McCormick.R.E.,Mitchell.M.L,1993,"Managerial Decision Making and Capital Structure",Journal of Business,pp.189-217.
• (45)Megginson,W.L.,2004,"Toward a Global Model of Venture Capital?",Journal of Applied Corporate Finance,16(1),pp.89-107.
• (46)Meyerson,D.and Martin,J.,1987,"Cultural Change:An Integration of Three Different Views",Journal of Management Studies,24(6),pp.623-647.
• (47)Moeller,S.B.,Schlingemann,F.P.,Stulz,R.M.,2004,"Firm Size and the Gains from Acquisitions",Journal of Financial Economics,73(2),pp.201-228.
• (48)Morck,R.,Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W.,1990,"Do Managerial Objectives Drive Bad Acquisitions?",The Journal of Finance,45(1),pp.31-48.
• (49)Morck,R.,Yeung,B.,Yu,W.,2000,"The Information Content of Stock Markets:Why Do Emerging Markets Have Synchronous Stock Price Movements?",Journal of Financial Economics,58(1),pp.215-260.
• (50)Moretti,E.,2004,"Workers'Education,Spillovers,and Productivity:Evidence from Plant-level Production Functions",American Economic Review,pp.656-690.
• (51)Morosini,P.,Shane,S.,Singh,H.,1998,"National Cultural Distance and Cross-border Acquisition Performance",Journal of International Business Studies,pp,137~158.
• (52)North,D.C.,1990,Institutions,Institutional Change and Economic Performance,Cambridge University Press.
• (53)Raghavendra Rau,P.and Vermaelen,T.,1998,"Glamour,Value and the Post-acquisition Performance of Acquiring Firms",Journal of Financial Economics,49(2),pp.223-253.
• (54)Sapienza,P.,Zingales,L.,Guiso,L.,2006,"Does Culture Affect Economic Outcomes?",National Bureau of Economic Research.
• (55)Schein,E.H.,1985,"Defining Organizational Culture",Classics of Organization Theory,3,pp.490-502.
• (56)Sharma,D.S.and Ho,J.,2002,"The Impact of Acquisitions on Operating Performance:some Australian Evidence",Journal of Business Finance&Accounting,29(1-2),pp.155-200.
• (57)Shleifer,A.and R.Vishny,1998,The Grabbing Hand:Government Pathologies and Their Cures,Harvard University Press.
• (58)Singh,H.and Montgomery,C.A.,1987,"Corporate Acquisition Strategies and Economic Performance",Strategic Management Journal,8(4),pp.377-386.
• (59)Song,W.,2007,"Does Overvaluation Lead to Bad Mergers?".AFA 2007 Chicago Meetings Paper.
• (60)Srensen.J.B..2002."The Strength of Corporate Culture and the Reliability of Firm Performance.Administrative Science Quarterly,47(1).pp.70~91.
• (61)Stahl,G.K.and A.Voigt,2008,"Do Cultural Differences Matter in Mergers and Acquisitions?A Tentative Model and Examination",Organization Science,19(1).pp.160-176.
• (62)Stigler,G.J.,1950,"Monopoly and Oligopoly by Merger".The American Economic Review,pp.23-34.
• (63)Teerikangas,S.and Very,P.,2006,"The Culture-performance Relationship in M&A:From Yes/No to How",British Journal of Management,17(S1),pp.S31-S48.
• (64)Tian.L.andEstrin.S..2008."Retained State Shareholding in Chinese Plcs:Does Government Ownership Always Reduce Corporate Value?,Journal of Comparative Economics,36(1),pp.74~89.
• (65)Weber,Y.and Drori,I.,2011,(下转第163页)(上接第157页)"Integrating Organizational and Human Behavior Perspectives on Mergers and Acquisitions",International Studies of Management and Organization,41(3),pp.76~95.
• (66)Weick,K.E.,1985,"The Significance of Corporate Culture",Organizational Culture,pp.381~389.
• (67)Zander,U.and L.Zander,2010,"Opening the Grey Box:Social Communities,Knowledge and Culture in Acquisitions".Journal of International Business Studies,41(1),pp.27~7.
• (68)白重恩、刘俏、陆洲、宋敏、张俊喜:《中国上市公司治理结构的实证研究》,《经济研研究》,2005年第2期。
• (69)陈传明、张敏:《企业文化的刚性特征:分析与测度》,《管理世界》,2005年第6期。
• (70)陈仕华、姜广省、卢昌崇:《董事联结、目标公司选择与并购绩效——基于并购双方之间信息不对称的研究视角》,《管理世界》,2013年第12期。
• (71)陈维政、忻蓉、王安逸:《企业文化与领导风格的协同性实证研究》,《管理世界》,2004年第2期。
• (72)费孝通:《中国社会学的成长》,《社会研究》,1947年。
• (73)郝铁川:《权利实现的差序格局》,《中国社会科学》,2002年第5期。
• (74)何铮、谭劲松、陆园园:《组织环境与组织战略关系的文献综述及最新研究动态》,《管理世界》,2007年第11期。
• (75)李善民、周小春:《公司特征、行业特征和并购战略类型的实证研究》,《管理世界》,2007年第3期。
• (76)刘志雄、张其仔:《企业文化对上市公司绩效的影响》,《财经问题研究》,2009年第2期。
• (77)牛晓健、郭东博、裘翔、张延:《供应链融资的风险测度与管理——基于中国银行交易数据的实证研究》,《金融研究》,2013年第11期。
• (78)潘红波、夏新平、余明桂:《政府干预、政治关联与地方国有企业并购》,《经济研究》,2008年第4期。
• (79)清科研究中心:《2013年中国并购市场年度研究报告》,2013年。
• (80)綦好东、黄跃群:《我国非上市国有企业信息公开披露:现状分析与制度设计》,《管理世界》,2009年第2期。
• (81)汤谷良、夏怡斐:《母公司文化控制力:中外合资企业文化陈述的差异与融合——基于中外合资汽车公司的多案例比较》,《管理世界》,2009年第2期。
• (82)唐建新、陈冬:《地区投资者保护、企业性质与异地并购的协同效应》,《管理世界》,2010年第8期。
• (83)王曾、符国群、黄丹阳、汪剑锋:《国有企业CEO"政治晋升”与“在职消费”关系研究》,《管理世界》,2014年第5期。
• (84)王化成、孙健、邓路、卢闯:《控制权转移中投资者过度乐观了吗?》,《管理世界》,2011年第2期。
• (85)王竹泉、隋敏:《控制结构+企业文化:内部控制要素新二元论》,《会计研究》,2010年第3期。
• (86)吴超鹏、吴世农、郑方镳:《管理者行为与连续并购绩效的理论与实证研究》,《管理世界》,2008年第7期。
• (87)颜士梅:《创业型并购不同阶段的知识员工整合风险及其成因——基于ASA模型的多案例分析》,《管理世界》,2012年第7期。
• (88)于天远、吴能全:《组织文化变革路径与政商关系——基于珠三角民营高科技企业的多案例研究》,《管理世界》,2012年第8期。
• (89)张新:《并购重组是否创造价值?——中国证券市场的理论与实证研究》,《经济研究》,2003年第6期。
• (90)郑志刚、许荣、徐向江、赵锡军:《公司章程条款的设立,法律对投资者权力保护和公司治理——基于我国A股上市公司的证据》,《管理世界》,2011年第7期。
• (91)郑志刚、殷慧峰、胡波:《我国非上市公司治理机制有效性的检验——来自我国制造业大中型企业的证据》,《金融研究》,2013年第2期。
• (92)钟宁桦:《公司治理与员工福利:来自中国非上市企业的证据》,《经济研究》,2012年第12期。
• (93)周小春、李善民:《并购价值创造的影响因素研究》,《管理世界》,2008年第5期。
• (94)朱华建、张盛勇、高宏伟:《21世纪以来我国内部控制研究主题及述评——基于2000年到2010年<会计研究>等国内主要七种期刊的分析》,《会计研究》,2011年第11期。
• ①参考定量研究企业文化的文献(Kotter and Heskett,1992;Sorensen,2002),本文将企业文化的量化指标简称为文化强度(Culture Strength),文化强度越高表示企业组织的共同价值观念认同越强。
• ②2007年以来中国并购市场并购事件数量与并购金额都基本保持增长态势,仅2013年全年中国并购市场共完成并购1232起(不包括属于关联交易的并购),同比上升24.3%,涉及的并购金额达932.03亿美元,同比涨幅为83.6%(清科研究中心,2013)。③2014年3月,国务院公布《关于进一步优化企业兼并重组市场环境的意见》,放松了在并购重组支付手段、定价等方面的政策要求;同年7月证监会在前期市场化改革的基础上发布《上市公司重大资产重组管理办法》,提出除借壳上市、发行股份外,上市公司重大资产重组不再需要经过证监会的行政许可。
• ④美国最适合工作公司榜(Best Companies to Work For in America)由最佳雇主学会(the Great Place to Work Institute)每年按照对超过40个国家的企业雇员的调查结果评选,http://www.greatplaceto work.com/our~approach/what-is-a-great-workplace。
• ⑤2010年4月15日,五部委(财政部、证监会、审计署、银监会、保监会)联合颁布《关于印发企业内部控制配套指引的通知》([2010]11号),明确内部控制包括5个相互联系的要素:控制环境、风险评估、控制活动、信息和沟通、监控。2012年8月14日,财政部与证监会联合发文《关于2012年主板上市公司分类分批实施企业内部控制规范体系的通知》([2012]30号),要求沪深上市公司每年定期披露内部控制审计报告。
• ⑥本文研究样本中收购方均为上市公司。⑦“差序格局”由社会学家费孝通先生在1947年《乡土中国》中提出,差序格局突出自我主义。在管理学中差序局主要应用于营销学研究,血缘、地域、经济发展水平、思维习惯、文化匹配度、势力范围是形成差序格局的主要因素。
• ⑧我们做这一处理的主要原因是通常只有形成控制权(相对)转移的并购事件才更可能涉及并购后的企业文化融合问题,我们也尝试了更严格地剔除并购后收购方股权比例不足51%的样本,即要求并购交易后收购方绝对控股目标公司,得到的主要结果保持一致。
• ⑨为了结论的稳健性,我们也尝试了保留收购方一年中并购规模最大的并购事件,或剔除一年内存在多起并购的样本等处理方式,得到的主要结果保持一致。参考Guest等(2004)、吴超鹏等(2008),我们在正文中报告“保留公司在当年所完成的第一起并购”的结果。
• ⑩并购首次公告日前后两年的总资产收益率平均变化量(△ROA_(t-2,t+2))即按并购完成之后两年(t+1年,t+2年)ROA均值减去并购前两年(t-2年,t-1年)ROA均值计算。
• 11.为了结论的稳健性,我们也使用了并购首次公告日前后1年(3年)的总资产收益率变化值作为长期并购绩效的度量指标,得到的结果保持一致,为节约报告空间,我们在正文中只报告了并购前后两年的总资产收益率变化值的结果。
• 12.参考已有文献(Singh and Montgomery,1987;Megginson et al.,2004;李善民、周小春,2007),我们将产业链中的上下游纵向并购和同一行业内的横向并购定义为行业相关性并购,相关行业企业文化可能更具有同质性。
• 13.使用并购前后1年或3年总资产收益率的变化的结果保持一致。
• 14.我们也考虑了同时改变企业文化强度和长期并购绩效的度量方式,即按刘志雄和张其仔(2009)的方法度量企业文化强度,检验其对使用并购前后1年至3年息税前利润与总资产比值变化度量的长期并购绩效的影响,回归结果仍与本文主要结果保持一致。